Chapter 12- Cathy Kelly

The List- Cathy Kelly

You were happy Catherine (otherwise known as Cathy Kelly) had gotten away from the business and branched out on her own. She had taken the split with Velveteen Dream hard and rumors about her and the guys from the undisputed era didn't help. She admitted she slept with Adam, and that caused some heat, but she didn't really mind. You two were close, not as close as you and Io but close enough that you never lied to her. She was following the gossip and always reached out and needed the scoop and you gave them. But whatever happened after Tegan had really set her off and she would not talk to you unless it was in person. Though the fifty messages asking you to come visit seemed to indicate otherwise. You worked on the road for a few days and decided to go stay with Cathy for your week off. She was ecstatic, she had been bored to tears since she left and life was hectic. So when you got there you got that winning smile, and the best and most sincere hug. She always made you feel like a champ even though you never wrestled. She wanted all the details immediately but you were tired and wanted a nap which she begrudgingly allows but only after a promise of sharing them once she finished dinner. You agree and within minutes of hitting the guest bed, you were out cold.

You awoke some time later and came into the living room, stretching and hazy as Cathy made the comment about you looking fairly like shit. You just shrug and take a seat before she tells you to get up and follow her into the kitchen. You do with a grumble as she makes a snarky remark and begins to prepare dinner as she tells you to spill. And you do, beat for beat, even spilling about the Neidharts and step which doesn't seem to catch her off guard. The food smelled great and she kept asking questions which you answer. Then she hit you with the one you weren't wanting to think about. "So ..what does this mean for you and Io?" You shrug. "I wish I knew...I wish I had an answer" she watches your face as she can feel your anguish and she does get best to assure you that it could always work out. You agreed half heartedly and she respected you enough to not press. Dinner was soon ready and grabbing some beers you headed out to her back patio and helped set up the yawning as the two of you ate, drank and then just talked for hours, which was always great as you enjoyed her company and she clearly had missed yours as she seemed different now that she was away from the business. She wasn't as reserved or stuck up as she had come off at times. She seemed at peace, and her glow was noticeable, she was always beautiful, but seeing her now made her seem more divine. 

"Do you ever think about me?" She asks innocently. You're not sure what she means and she sorta hangs her head. "I know how you think of Io...and I always, I don't know, that it was nice for someone to think that way about someone…" she trails off as she doesn't want to finish the thought as you smile and come over to her, rubbing her shoulders as she lays her hand on one of yours as you massage her. "Cathy... you're not just a notch...I think about you but just...not in that way...not because I don't want you...but because you're more than that to me…" she snickers and looks up at you. "You can still think that...but do you ever wonder about what I think about it?" She looks at you quizzically as you don't know what to say, Cathy standing as she turns and grips your face in her hands, looking into your eyes as she searches for her words. "I want you...even if you don't want me the same way...but I want you even for a night…" you don't know what to say but she doesn't give you an option as she kisses you, her lips fitting perfectly against you as you begin kissing each other passionately, losing yourself in the moment as she pulls away soon after, her forehead touching yours as she trembles. "Have me...please...just...even if I'm a notch...even if I…" you shut her up by kissing her, hoisting her into your arms as she wraps her arms and legs around you, the two of you lost in the moment before you move towards the patio doors Cathy getting down as she opens it and takes your hand, leading you back inside. 

Cathy was virtually perfect from head to toe. Literally. Her toes, her legs, her ass and hips. Her stomach, her breasts, her neckline and amazing facial features, it was all put together with perfect symmetry. Her naked frame stood before you a beacon of pure genetic perfection and as you felt a tinge of awkwardness standing naked before her, she had calmed your nerves by being on her knees, your cock sliding in her mouth as she would only suck on the head a few inches, the rest of your cock was being slowly stroked in her soft hands as she was doing this as graceful as you had ever had this done before, it was the mixing of pleasure and passion, her tongue was rolling along your cock as she would kiss the tip and stroke and give a look up as if she was asking for acceptance, she looked amazing doing this and it was only a matter of time before you felt the churning and the throbbing that would begin before you came. You take her onto her back on her four posted bed and wrapping her legs around your waist you line your cock up and begin to push inside her pussy, doing this slowly as she was gasping and gripping your back as she was already soaking wet, and as you were able to get the sixth and half inch inside you began to rock, slowly and lovingly as she kissed you and held you tightly against her, her breasts heaving as her nipples were hard and grazing against you as your hips were moving nice and slow, your dick sliding in and out, getting harder and throbbing within a matter of minutes as this was different. This was simply fucking, this was more intimate. She cried out not soon afterward you began to throb and stretch her cunt out as she shudder and whimpered from her orgasm, her pussy becoming even more wetter than it was before as you stopped for a few moments before, Cathy kissing you as she sucked in some quick breaths and taps your back, which you take as a sign that she wants you to keep going, you begin rocking again, the same way you had before, the sound of your cock plunging into her wet pussy was audible and soon you felt the release of your first powerful orgasm ripping through your cock and into her womb, Cathy moaning loudly as she dug her fingers into your back, your body shakes as your dick was pulsing out cum into her pussy, deep and throbbing, the sensation was too much as you felt dizzy. Her hands rubbed your back after you had stopped and let out a few "mmmm" noises, she kissed your face and held your face up to hers. "Your mine tonight…" you don't disagree and she smiles and lays a soft kiss before reaching down and grabbing your ass as she keeps you inside of her. "fuck me hard...I like it when someone keeps fucking me even after they came..it's so hot…"

You start grinding your hips as she encourages you, motivating you with her words and her hands pulling you to go faster and harder, the sound of your cock stirring her insides like when you stir mad and cheese, a sloshing sound that makes your cock rock hard as you begin plunging your dick inside of her, Cathy letting go as she moans out "oh yeah mmmm just like that fuck yes just like that…" trailing off as she cums, her body shaking as you fucked her with a primal abandon, Cathy unable to control her body as she shook and squirmed and grabbed at the sheets, screaming and moaning and crying out, multiple orgasms cresting through out her body as for minutes on end you piledrive your dick into her and as another countless orgasm washes through her system, you fire off a second orgasm, cumming inside her filled cunt once again but only for the first few spurts before you pull out and spray the rest into her pussy lips and along her stomach and waist. She curls up and moans as she twitches, your body's sweaty messes, as you lay beside her, breathing wildly as she curled up next to you. You don't say anything for a long while, just laying together in a sweaty geap as she eventually runs a hand along your chest and looks up at you. "You want to be with Io...I want to be with you...so...so how about this...we...we be together...no strings... absolutely no strings. I know how it is out there and I am not expecting you to change your life up cuz you're with me. But...maybe...maybe we can make this a regular thing. You staying with me...us...is that something, I don't know it sounds dumb but is that something you would even consider?" You take a moment and kiss her forehead and nod, giving her a yes or course as she smiled and lays her head on your chest. "I guess you can add me on that little notch list of yours'', she says sarcastically. You try to hold back a laugh but she laughs first so you do the same, making the mental note to yourself that you could indeed cross Cathy Kelly off the list. You two talk for a few hours, still naked in bed about how this would work. Once you both felt comfortable with where you guys stood on the matter, she blew you for a half hour until you came down her throat and fell asleep not soon after she had finished. The next week went by with a flurry of sexual romps, but just tender normal moments. Video game trash talking, workouts and watching some mini series that was really good. When the time came to head back onto the road she let you blow one last load inside her cunt as you fucked her over her little office chair, smacking her ass as it bounced against you before you had finished blowing your load. She tells you to be safe and call her when you reach your hotel, and giving her a kiss goodbye you depart, your heart a bit in your throat to watch her face away from view. Things were happening so rapidly, and you weren't sure what was going to happen next. 

End.