A Naughty Affair: Fake Dating My Ex Boyfriend's Brothers

394·Goofy

Why have one brother when I can have all three? “Is this what you do every time we’re not here?' he asks. “You get yourself off like this?” I shake my head, fucking myself on the dildo. “No. No, it’s just today,” I gasp out. “I just… needed it.” Luke’s jaw clenches. “I’ve heard you. At night.” My stomach flips. I thought I was being quiet, but I guess not quiet enough. “Luke—” He cuts me off. “I’ve heard you in your room, whimpering my brothers’ names. Elijah and Benedict both.” Fuck. There’s not even anything I can say to argue that because he’s right. Between the dream about Elijah and what happened with Benedict at the bakery, they’ve been going in circles on my mind lately. “I’ve been listening,” Luke admits, his voice dropping into something like a growl. “I’ve been waiting to hear you say my name. I’ve been wanting to hear it.” “Oh.” My movements stutter a bit at that revelation. He seems… jealous. I wouldn’t have thought Luke felt that emotion, considering how he’s always holding himself apart from everyone else, but knowing that he heard me and that he wanted me to say his name just makes me blush even more. Because I have touched myself to thoughts of him too, of course I have. But I must have stifled those noises better that time than the others. So he doesn’t know. “Do you think about me too?” Luke asks, moving in even closer, until he’s filling the space between the shower and the counter and all I can see is him. I nod, biting my lip. “Show me,” he orders. “Show me what you think about. How much you want it.” I didn’t mean to tell my entire family that I’m dating my ex’s three older brothers…But to be fair, the lie wasn’t even my fault. When my ex asked if I’d be bringing a plus-one to his holiday wedding (to my sister, by the way–don’t even get me started about that), I did what any self-respecting woman would do and said of course. I probably should’ve been prepared for followup questions, but when my ex asked who I’m dating, I drew a complete blank.That’s when his three gorgeous older brothers spoke up… at the same time. Now my family thinks I’m dating all three of them, and Elijah, Luke, and Benedict are staying in my too-small house for the holidays. To make things even more complicated, they don’t seem to get along at all, and I may have given my v-card to Elijah six years ago before he ghosted me after one night.I don’t have time for this! My life is chaotic enough as it is, trying to keep my tiny bakery afloat during the Christmas rush. The last thing I need is Benefit eyeing my curves as if he actually appreciates them, Luke barging in on me while I’m doing something very naughty in the shower, and Elijah admitting that he hasn’t slept with anyone else since that night. This is all supposed to be fake… even if the tension between us feels alarmingly real.I already fell for one Montgomery brother and got my heart broken. What would happen if I dare to let myself fall for three?